dominionhobby.com Randall Made Knife
The RANDALL KNIFE FORUMS

A place where EVERYBODY is welcome to join in on the discussion of Randall Made knives


Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 14 15 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#126065 - 04/08/15 08:37 PM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? * [Re: Joe Tousignant]
Dirty_Water Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 09/13/05
Posts: 2304
Loc: central fl.
Insults? Where?

What I was saying was that RMK doesn't need the extra money you keep saying what these options would bring...it's not necessary...

I guess what I've heard about you is also true...

I'm not going to participate in another on and on and on sheath type thread...I'm out...argue with yourself....I comment, as you wanted on your altered knife and YOU do nothing but insult me since...tired of your nonsensical verbage...

Argue away, I'm blocking this thread...

---DW---
_________________________
---DW---


Scott
RKS #014

HE IS RISEN!, HE IS RISEN INDEED!

Top
#126067 - 04/08/15 08:40 PM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Joe Tousignant]
TonyLaPetri Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 10/05/05
Posts: 6904
Loc: Glen Head NY
Bottom line ...

You ask for peoples' opinions, you're going to get them. No need to argue and
bash people for something you asked for. You should have expected differing opinions.

Seems like you shouldn't have asked in the first place.
_________________________
Tony LaPetri
RKS#1885
RKCC CM-022

Top
#126070 - 04/08/15 08:53 PM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Joe Tousignant]
Tom Vaught Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 04/26/10
Posts: 574
Loc: Michigan
I was personally happy to see Joe come on as a new member of the Knifetalk Forums. New members/thoughts are always a good thing.

I am sorry though that personal comments about members have been posted. Scott (Dirty Water) started off on the ground floor and over the years worked his way up to where he is managing the everyday knife making of the shop, still doing given tasks in the knife making process, and devoting time to the given knife events around the country.

I think that you are missing one large point in this discussion. Mr GARY RANDALL makes the decisions on what he wants to sell, etc so complaining to Scott is misdirected I feel.

Scott has his opinion on the mods you have made, I have my opinion, others have theirs. You made the original post and clearly stated that it was a customized knife configuration. Not everyone likes a given customization, be it a knife, a bike, a car, a boat. Why don't we leave it at that.

Tom Vaught



Edited by Tom Vaught (04/08/15 08:54 PM)
_________________________
Tom Vaught
RKS# 5100

Top
#126079 - 04/08/15 10:43 PM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Tom Vaught]
CrazyCajun Online
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 10/08/12
Posts: 2051
Loc: Central Florida
Well Boy'z.... I remember the day when I was glad to have a knife and something to use it on. I grew up in Pine Hills Florida! At that time it seemed like God's Country> It is now Crime Hills.

In regards to life/knife/and strife if I have to live my life concerned about sheaths/ steel/ customizations/ makers.... than I no longer need to play.

Real, factual, and non personal attack styles are where I am at. If I can't get that.... I'll watch and BELIEVE the news!
I am going to break out a 70's folder..... catch a fish.... and live!
_________________________
Steve Daugherty
RKCC CM #051
NRA Member
FlA Knife Makers Assoc.

Top
#126081 - 04/08/15 11:23 PM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Dirty_Water]
Joe Tousignant Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 06/20/14
Posts: 90
Loc: Upstate New York
Originally Posted By: Dirty_Water
Insults? Where?

What I was saying was that RMK doesn't need the extra money you keep saying what these options would bring...it's not necessary...

I guess what I've heard about you is also true...

I'm not going to participate in another on and on and on sheath type thread...I'm out...argue with yourself....I comment, as you wanted on your altered knife and YOU do nothing but insult me since...tired of your nonsensical verbage...

Argue away, I'm blocking this thread...

---DW---


I find it rather ironic that "I" am charged with insulting Scott, where the exact opposite can be judged from his initial post in this thread and subsequent later ones. I believe any fair minded reader through the posts would find the same. I fully expected contrary opinions and even some light hearted abuse, or else I wouldn't have posted the modifications. But some of the viciousness thrown my way was uncalled for,...and yet I can deal with it.

Maybe Scott is acting out of some "defensive" posture,.....that somehow my Randall wasn't up to some mythical standard expected of a Randall. Perhaps he felt insulted,....and that was not my intent.

In all fairness, I do understand Randall is a small company, and can't be expected to have unlimited models and choices. But I will never understand the logic behind minor changes in a "hand made" knife on models they already make. The fact that even leaving off a labor step (thumb notches for instance) is a "NO" only adds to my frustration.

There should be legitimate reasons for a business ever saying "NO" to a customer, especially one willing to wait FIVE freaking years for delivery! Without a reasonable explanation, just not feeling like it doesn't make sense. (or "cents" either for what could be add on charges) I'm not surprised RMK doesn't need the extra money. With the heavy workload, several years out order bookings, and premium pricing in the marketplace, .....that DOES make sense.

The fact is that EVERY knife is a compromise in some way, and not one made anywhere will be the perfect knife in every situation.

Randall's have a well earned reputation for quality and toughness, and I don't disagree with that. But that toughness is achieved primarily through being a bit overbuilt on some knives, if you will.

Sportsman's knives are my main interest, and I honestly think it is one area of the Randall line that would be made more "useful" with a less than 3/16" blade stock thickness. While I'd prefer a bit thinner stock (5/32" maybe making for a little lighter knife overall on the sportsman models),.... I think thinning the blade forward of the hilt would do as well on the 3/16" stock sportsman knives.

As has been pointed out with all the "NO's", that isn't going to happen any time soon. So I make changes to get close to what I need or want. (and I venture a guess others have also, as I was informed of one from many years ago) Several of my dedicated bushcrafer knives are quite close, so the geometry of what works best is no trade secret.

Most sportsman don't need a knife thick enough to break into a car's door,.......but getting through a bunch of cucumbers or carrots shouldn't be an effort either with something like the model 26 Pathfinder. It does the job,....but not as easy as my forged 1/8" thick Billy Watson period style flat ground blade.

Cleaning game and fish also doesn't require a thick blade, but other than the Model 10 series of knives there is little offered in the line for an optimum slicing tool, or optimum for woodcrafting and bushcraft duties. The handles are a bit thin there for me also, but could be re-handled of course.



Anyway,....lets see some of your other "mods" out there..... laugh



Edited by Joe Tousignant (04/09/15 03:18 AM)

Top
#126082 - 04/09/15 12:02 AM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Joe Tousignant]
tunefink Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 09/13/05
Posts: 4068
Loc: Bambalam
Joe, I am all for you modifying a knife to fit your needs and stylistic desires. You own it, do what you will.

Several people here have had Randalls rehandled and even refinished with hammer marked blades, especially by James Behring. I have a Randall kit knife that he finished for me..... and I really like it. Most (none) have not reshaped the blades.

I am in the process of having a run of Randal APFK's "customized" to my specs. The blade grinds will nor be altered, but none the less, they will not be stock Randalls. I will share the results once I get the first 10 knives back from my guy.


I am curious..... and this is a serious question.

What are "woodcrafting" and "bushcraft" duties. I have spent a day or two in the woods and I have never used those two terms to describe my knife related activities.

Could you elaborate on those two terms and what the mean in camp?
_________________________
Always, buying, selling and trading.
www.randallmadeknife.com

Top
#126085 - 04/09/15 01:00 AM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Joe Tousignant]
Chief Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 12/05/05
Posts: 5414
Loc: Baton Rouge, Louisiana
But some of the viciousness thrown my way was uncalled for,...and yet I can deal with it.

Maybe Scott is acting out of some "defensive" posture,.....that somehow my Randall wasn't up to some mythical standard expected of a Randall. Perhaps he felt insulted,....and that was not my intent.

If you can "deal with it" then please do so & stick to your topic.

Using terms like "defensive posture" & "mythical standard" followed by
Perhaps he felt insulted,....and that was not my intent.

I could argue that either way.

Most of this.......tirade, is about what you think Randall knives lack in business practices in customization, your opinion how they should make the sportsman models a 1/32 thinner so they would be more useful, a thicker blade by 1/32 or 1/16 makes slicing cucumbers & carrots harder?

your original topic - Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here?

You are asking for the shop to do the customizing by telling them what you think would make their product better. It's Randall made not Randall custom made to order.

By all means customize away to make your knife look & function as you see fit. Feel free to post them & show us. But lets leave it at that please.
_________________________
See Ya, Chief
RKCC CM-037
RKS #5154

If you put off following The LORD just remember......They don't serve breakfast in hell!

Top
#126086 - 04/09/15 02:10 AM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: tunefink]
Joe Tousignant Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 06/20/14
Posts: 90
Loc: Upstate New York
Originally Posted By: tunefink
Joe, I am all for you modifying a knife to fit your needs and stylistic desires. You own it, do what you will.

Several people here have had Randalls rehandled and even refinished with hammer marked blades, especially by James Behring. I have a Randall kit knife that he finished for me..... and I really like it. Most (none) have not reshaped the blades.

I am in the process of having a run of Randal APFK's "customized" to my specs. The blade grinds will nor be altered, but none the less, they will not be stock Randalls. I will share the results once I get the first 10 knives back from my guy.


I am curious..... and this is a serious question.

What are "woodcrafting" and "bushcraft" duties. I have spent a day or two in the woods and I have never used those two terms to describe my knife related activities.

Could you elaborate on those two terms and what the mean in camp?


For me "bushcrafting" entails most EVERY aspect of being as comfortable and self suffecient for extended time periods in a remote wooded area. Shelter building, basic firewood processing and kindling, fire starting thru anything from primitave means to more modern means, food prep and outdoor cooking methods,...and MANY more individual aspects of setting up and maintaining a comfortable woods camp.

There is a lot of overlap, and most folks have their own personal thoughts on various aspects of the hobby and what categories a task should be placed in. It's not critical as far as I'm concerned.

"Woodcrafting" in my mind is a bit more specialized, in that I'd include making wooden tools and utility items for use in camp. Things such as spoons and forks, bowls, fire making bow and related parts, making and setting snares and deadfalls, making more complicated wooden shelters with beds and campfire cooking setups, primitive weapon making,...etc,......

A thinner bladed spear pointed knife seems to work best for me, and to date I have had my thinned out Model 26 Pathfinder out on a few occasions. (the subject of my 1st modified knife in this thread)

This 01 tool steel blade works well with that knife, although I'd like it even better without any choil. Fortunately it has a short and fairly shallow one, and I've adjusted to that.



Edited by Joe Tousignant (04/09/15 03:22 AM)

Top
#126087 - 04/09/15 02:33 AM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Chief]
Joe Tousignant Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 06/20/14
Posts: 90
Loc: Upstate New York
Originally Posted By: Chief
But some of the viciousness thrown my way was uncalled for,...and yet I can deal with it.

Maybe Scott is acting out of some "defensive" posture,.....that somehow my Randall wasn't up to some mythical standard expected of a Randall. Perhaps he felt insulted,....and that was not my intent.

If you can "deal with it" then please do so & stick to your topic.

Using terms like "defensive posture" & "mythical standard" followed by
Perhaps he felt insulted,....and that was not my intent.

I could argue that either way.

Most of this.......tirade, is about what you think Randall knives lack in business practices in customization, your opinion how they should make the sportsman models a 1/32 thinner so they would be more useful, a thicker blade by 1/32 or 1/16 makes slicing cucumbers & carrots harder?

your original topic - Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here?

You are asking for the shop to do the customizing by telling them what you think would make their product better. It's Randall made not Randall custom made to order.

By all means customize away to make your knife look & function as you see fit. Feel free to post them & show us. But lets leave it at that please.


I see your point, and at least it's fair minded and reasonable.

However, the shop DOES have options available, and choices in SS or 01 carbon on some models, differing grinds on a few, "old style" blade shape or new style on some, or with added thumb grooves or initials on most models I think. There is even an "Examples Customizations" page,......so obviously there are a lot of hands on option changes available already. Offering these options and having many others available can be considered "Randall custom made to order" to a limited extant.

This does make it in some ways a custom shop, otherwise NO options would be offered for any model. I just can't understand the rational with not being able to accommodate a customer by leaving the thumb grooves off or leaving off a false top edge,.....things like that.

RMK is not "my" business for sure, but I do think I have a valid point in bringing some of this up. They have such a huge and loyal customer base, but the hairs went up on my arms reading some of the comments made recently.

There were way too many years running my own jewelry repair service at a local mall, where I was a one man shop acting as an independent contractor on site. (50-50 split)

I'm not ashamed to say I did fine jewelry repair and diamond setting. If on the rare occasion "I" wasn't happy with the way a job came out,...I did it over,...on me. My standard for that judgement was "if" I was doing the job for myself,....would I be satisfied with it?

As you probably know by know, I AM a bit fussy and know what I want. The customer "got" as good as I would get for myself. They were important to my future. They talked to their friends and relatives,...I got more work. A "win-win" on a small scale.

The customer was always satisfied or I made changes occasionally to make it so. Sometime I think it's part of my DNA by now. I did this work for over 35 years after starting as an apprentice at age 15 in High School working part time, which is why I truly don't understand the thinking there. At least you have a better understanding why I have trouble with all this.

I always had 80 to 150 jobs in front of me at the mall location, which was great because if I didn't have work in front of me, I wasn't getting paid. Strictly a 50/50 split on work produced, after deducting part costs. The mall was open 7 days a week most of the year, and I regularly worked 70 hour 7 day weeks. Two weeks before Christmas there were 100+ hours put in during those weeks, and I crashed and slept through Christmas most years. The ONLY days I took off all year were the 3 days a year the Mall closed. (Christmas, Easter, and Thanksgiving).

I only mention all of this because I took my customer's interests and expectations to heart. My customer's mattered,..... what they wanted mattered. If I had to say "no" on any part of a job, I had a valid reason for saying it and offered it. "The head to set your shape of diamond is not available in that style, but I can get it for you in this style". That's understandable and logical, and I'd have no problem with those types of reasons yo say no. But I literally cringe when I hear such lack of appreciation for so many loyal customers willing to wait in that 5 year backlog. We can't leave off usually added in finger grooves or false spine edges on this model,.......but hey,......wait 5 years anyway and get something that's not totally what you wanted? That concept (to leave out one or more of the usually added in model features) is so foreign to the way I thought of my own customers I can't even begin to express how it makes me feel,....but it starts at feeling bad for other fans of these knives I don't even know personally.

I'm probably getting too old now to have any of this affect me directly. I doubt I could wait 5 years or more for a new factory ordered knife,.....I'd be over 64 when it arrived. Thru a dealer might be possible with an earlier spot, but maybe just talking about such things openly will help some of you younger fans of Randall Made Knives.

What harm is there to actually say "yes" to these kinds of requests that require LESS time and work to make a happier customer? The workman already have a list of "options" for that particular knife order. Is it really going to double the time to make the knife if they leave off a few steps normally done? (remember the 5 year expanding to 10 year wait that was presented if they didn't say "NO" to requests like this) Just not going to happen,.....because if it did there are much more serious issues causing it than saying no to leaving off usual steps.

It used to be said that "the customer is always right", and I sort of always worked and felt that way. (God that sounds pretty old fashioned,....now that I'm writing it) BUT there were plenty of times the customer was just dead wrong too! Time to bite your tongue and look at the bigger picture.

It didn't matter in the long term, because I NEEDED my customers to keep coming back! They paid my bills,...they mattered to my own well being and future income. But when you have a huge backup maybe it doesn't count anymore.

Several times a day I got up from my workbench to wait on a customer during busy times. I wasn't paid for this, as the repair work produced was my only compensation. Sometimes I even made a pricy sale for the store,.....and nothing came my way money wise. That was OK though, I made plenty with the hours I put in.

I realized the "customer" wouldn't know WHY I wasn't helping them if I continued to work at the bench, if all the other clerks were tied up. I felt they would be frustrated that someone "working" at the store was ignoring them,.....as they didn't know our arrangement. So I waited on them it, and it did affect my own pay to a small extent. Time away from my bench was time I wasn't earning. But the customer mattered, and we (I) needed them back again and again.

Anyway,....I'm going to let this go,.....as "someone" has already sent me a PM warning of sorts. So much for open dialogue.



Edited by Joe Tousignant (04/09/15 07:37 PM)

Top
#126088 - 04/09/15 09:21 AM Re: Any In The Closet Randall Knife Customizers Here? [Re: Joe Tousignant]
TAH Offline
Knife Enthusiast

Registered: 10/26/05
Posts: 2382
Loc: USA
Joe,

Not sure if you saw this conversion, but I thought this project was pretty cool.

Link
_________________________
Tom
RKS #4233

Top
Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 14 15 >


Moderator:  Mr_Mod