Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! - Knifetalk Forums

'; echo ''; echo '' . $arr[$ad1] . ''; echo '' . $arr[$ad2] . ''; echo ''; echo ''; ?>

You are not logged in. [Log In] Knifetalk Forums » Forums » Outdoor Forum - Are you getting Outside? » Fishing and Boating Tales » Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)!

Page 10 of 50

10

Topic Options

Rate This Topic

#140656 - 04/23/16 06:53 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: JerryG]
Chief Knife Enthusiast Registered: 12/05/05 Posts: 5414 Loc: Baton Rouge, Louisiana	Originally Posted By: JerryG So what options are ya thinkin of on that one Chief?? As I've said, too big for my uses but I'd like to see where you're headed. I would put a nickel silver hilt on it just because I like it better than brass. A border patrol handle / no butt cap Thong hole Red or black micarta Spacers to match micarta / thong also (if possible) I like that it's a 3/16 blade Lots of folks commenting on how big knives aren't all that for cleaning small fish. I disagree (go figure) when I'm cleaning fish I find the thickness & height of the blade to be more important than the length of the blade. When I do the skin side of the filet I am mostly holding the skin down at the tail end, & pushing the blade with minimal sawing motion of the blade. If another 1-3 inches of blade is sticking out on either side of the filet so what. I would rather clean a small fish with a big knife than a big fish with a small knife. Keep in mind if you are fishing & camping, staying over night at a camp, you will be cooking. This knife works in the kitchen as well. _________________________ See Ya, Chief RKCC CM-037 RKS #5154 If you put off following The LORD just remember......They don't serve breakfast in hell!
Top

#140657 - 04/23/16 07:25 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Chief]
pappy19 Knife Enthusiast Registered: 10/31/07 Posts: 7437 Loc: Garden Valley, Idaho	Agreed Chief. Most common SOB filet Knives are all 6-8" long and the thickness is what counts more than the length. If you are cleaning a trout, all you need is a pocket knife to go up the vent. Pap _________________________ Mike Allen RKCC-CM-086 True West Magazine Maniac Randall Collector Behring Made Collector Ruana Collector Glock Fan NRA- Life Member since 1975 mikenlu99@aol.com
Top

#140658 - 04/23/16 07:43 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: pappy19]
BladesNBarrels Knife Enthusiast Registered: 09/19/05 Posts: 1414 Loc: East Tincup General Store,Colo...	Most of the time I am using a fishing knife for trout in the mountains. 3 Steps: 1. Cut open the fish with a sharp knife. Try to cut in a straight line up along the underbelly. a. Lay the trout flat on a cutting board or other flat surface. Hold the fish down on the cutting board with your left hand. b. Try to cut one clean line through the bottom of the fish. Don’t cut into the guts. 2. Remove the internal organs. Reach into the body cavity to remove the intestines, heart, and other organs. a. Scrape out the organs with a spoon or pull the organs out with your hand. Put your spoon or hand through the cut open fish. b. Try not to let any organs break open as this can spread disease. Throw the organs away when you are done. 3. Remove the spine. Identify the spine as a blood red line that goes from head to tail on the uppermost part of the fish. a. Scrape out the spine with your thumb or a spoon. Scrape from the tail to the gills. b. Take this opportunity to remove any guts that remain. Make sure to wash out all organs and blood. Scrape any organs out that you can’t wash away. Attachments ------ ------ ------ _________________________ David Loomis RKS# 724 RKCC# CM-061 Molon Labe
Top

#140659 - 04/23/16 07:53 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: pappy19]
JerryG Knife Enthusiast Registered: 11/04/11 Posts: 327 Loc: WI	Thanks for the explanation Chief! I like your choice of options, I'd go for red micarta instead of the usual black. 1/4" is too thick in most instances, grind dependent of course. I'm sure height of blade is a factor, but every filet knife I've used tapers quickly to a point. Very little thickness there. When cutting the meat from the skin, I agree, extra length doesn't matter. Getting to that point in the process is a different story, at least with the "bait" I catch up here. I think your fish are much taller, belly to dorsal fin, than what I catch. That would make a big difference in the appropriate tool. I'd much rather clean the occasional big fish with the little knife instead of the other way around. And a 9" camp knife seems a bit much, at least for me. This build going to be fun to see come together! _________________________ Jerry
Top

#140660 - 04/23/16 08:07 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: BladesNBarrels]
Chief Knife Enthusiast Registered: 12/05/05 Posts: 5414 Loc: Baton Rouge, Louisiana	Originally Posted By: BladesNBarrels Most of the time I am using a fishing knife for trout in the mountains. 3 Steps: 1. Cut open the fish with a sharp knife. Try to cut in a straight line up along the underbelly. a. Lay the trout flat on a cutting board or other flat surface. Hold the fish down on the cutting board with your left hand. b. Try to cut one clean line through the bottom of the fish. Don’t cut into the guts. 2. Remove the internal organs. Reach into the body cavity to remove the intestines, heart, and other organs. a. Scrape out the organs with a spoon or pull the organs out with your hand. Put your spoon or hand through the cut open fish. b. Try not to let any organs break open as this can spread disease. Throw the organs away when you are done. 3. Remove the spine. Identify the spine as a blood red line that goes from head to tail on the uppermost part of the fish. a. Scrape out the spine with your thumb or a spoon. Scrape from the tail to the gills. b. Take this opportunity to remove any guts that remain. Make sure to wash out all organs and blood. Scrape any organs out that you can’t wash away. WOW that's to much like work!!! Maybe we should just invent a sharp spoon! _________________________ See Ya, Chief RKCC CM-037 RKS #5154 If you put off following The LORD just remember......They don't serve breakfast in hell!
Top

#140661 - 04/23/16 08:09 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Chief]
Chief Knife Enthusiast Registered: 12/05/05 Posts: 5414 Loc: Baton Rouge, Louisiana	Jerry how big is the bait you are cutting up, just out of curiosity? _________________________ See Ya, Chief RKCC CM-037 RKS #5154 If you put off following The LORD just remember......They don't serve breakfast in hell!
Top

#140662 - 04/23/16 08:31 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Chief]
Captain Chris Stanaback Knife Enthusiast Registered: 09/14/05 Posts: 12867 Loc: Central Florida	Electric knives for 90% of my fish-cleaning tasks. Capt. Chris _________________________ Capt.Chris Stanaback RKCC/RKCA Founder RKS #016 NRA Lifetime Member CAPTSTANABACK@aol.com WEBSITE: www.captstanaback.com
Top

#140663 - 04/23/16 08:31 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Chief]
maxpastor Knife Enthusiast Registered: 07/31/14 Posts: 849 Loc: South West	Originally Posted By: Chief Originally Posted By: JerryG So what options are ya thinkin of on that one Chief?? As I've said, too big for my uses but I'd like to see where you're headed. I would put a nickel silver hilt on it just because I like it better than brass. A border patrol handle / no butt cap Thong hole Red or black micarta Spacers to match micarta / thong also (if possible) I like that it's a 3/16 blade Lots of folks commenting on how big knives aren't all that for cleaning small fish. I disagree (go figure) when I'm cleaning fish I find the thickness & height of the blade to be more important than the length of the blade. When I do the skin side of the filet I am mostly holding the skin down at the tail end, & pushing the blade with minimal sawing motion of the blade. If another 1-3 inches of blade is sticking out on either side of the filet so what. I would rather clean a small fish with a big knife than a big fish with a small knife. Keep in mind if you are fishing & camping, staying over night at a camp, you will be cooking. This knife works in the kitchen as well. So Chief, are you leaning toward the Model 4 with a larger blade, like the one you posted on the second page? would that knife have a top edge sharpened, with the embellishments you suggested? max _________________________ "Political correctness is a doctrine, fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and rabidly promoted by an unscrupulous mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition that it is entirely possible to pick up a turd by the clean end." RKCC #502
Top

#140664 - 04/23/16 08:40 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Chief]
JerryG Knife Enthusiast Registered: 11/04/11 Posts: 327 Loc: WI	Originally Posted By: Chief Jerry how big is the bait you are cutting up, just out of curiosity? Mostly panfishing. About 10" bluegill, 14" crappie with an occasional walleye around 24" or northern pike around 30" or better. _________________________ Jerry
Top

#140665 - 04/23/16 08:42 PM Re: Springtime Fishing (& a new Randall build)! [Re: Captain Chris Stanaback]
JerryG Knife Enthusiast Registered: 11/04/11 Posts: 327 Loc: WI	Originally Posted By: Captain Chris Stanaback Electric knives for 90% of my fish-cleaning tasks. Capt. Chris I've been thinking about giving one of those a try....... but then there wouldn't be any reason for this build!! _________________________ Jerry
Top

Page 10 of 50

10

View All Topics

Hop to:

Moderator: TonyLaPetri