It's been my experience, Larry, that there appears to be no difference as to edge "holding ability" one tother. The difference is in re-sharpening (shaping) the blade...carbon is faster-n-easier.
I think the preponderance of opinion and preference for carbon stems from it's ability in starting a fire. Of course...that being said...I carry heavy-duty, waterproof matches also.
It is my opinion that the majority of "stainless advocates" deem it so...."only" because of it's ability to resist rust-n-tarnish.
My opinion,
Capt. Chris

Update: It's 6-3, thus far, with carbon leading the charge....just sayin'. I'll give it until Sunday evening. I'm surprised no more responses...
Capt. Chris

I'm ready to move on to the hilt and handle area lol

Carbon

Pap

Captain--

I like both steels...but...

If looking for a knife that I don't want to develop freckles or outright rust, go for stainless.

I was glad to see RMK move on from the O1 forgings for the Sergeant's Special that they had struck and had in stock for Stoddard's. Every one I owned developed freckles or worse. Maybe because of the lot that those O1 forgings came from???

Which reminds me that I need to dig out the one I still have and see if it is OK.

With RMKs...I have too many favorites, can't own or use them all.

And I will be happy with whichever steel the players select for this build.

Larry

Stainless is painless
For maintenance that is.

I'm "slammed" this morning as my A/C tech is here and I have no air, while his maintenance is done...about 3-4 hours. Is someone would be so kind as to tally the blade steel preference, I would be most thankful.
Thanks,
Capt. Chris

I'll tell ya'...It's "slow-going" on this build. The final count is:
A) Carbon-7 votes
B) Stainless-4 votes
We're done. Let's move on, thanks.
Capt. Chris

If anyone is out there, please let me know? Hilt, spacers or collar, handle material, etc. etc...Anybody?
Capt. Chris

I'm Here and will kick off the Hilt discussion.

Nickel silver single squared paired with Black / Alum spacers.