This Old Randall - Knifetalk Forums

The RANDALL KNIFE FORUMS

A place where EVERYBODY is welcome to join in on the discussion of Randall Made knives

You are not logged in. [Log In] Knifetalk Forums » Forums » Randall Knife Talk » Randall Made Knives » This Old Randall

Page 9 of 171

9

Topic Options

Rate This Topic

#25752 - 09/30/07 03:28 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: BoBlade]
boardrider Knife Enthusiast Registered: 01/12/06 Posts: 685 Loc: Malibu CA, USA	Is the handle pinned ivory in your opinion? It sure looks like it but how often do you see this vintage of ivory that crack/check free, it usually cracks at the pin at least usually more. Also what do you think of the shape of the handle? The blade looks right to me but no trademark? All in all more questions than answers. The kids in my neighborhood would call this "one Killer knife" pun intended. Griff Snyder RKS #63 _________________________ G Snyder RKS #63 RKCC "REMEMBER, YOU CAN NEVER GO WRONG BY COLLECTING OR OWNING THE BEST" http://www.knife-collectibles.com
Top

#25753 - 09/30/07 04:51 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: boardrider]
BigJim Knife Enthusiast Registered: 05/03/06 Posts: 1054	Ron, A wild guess. Could the knife have been ordered from the shop"sterile"? GOD BLESS OUR TROOPS!!! _________________________ Jim P. NRA Life The Only Place I want to see a liberal is in a Museum
Top

#25754 - 09/30/07 05:50 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: BigJim]
boardrider Knife Enthusiast Registered: 01/12/06 Posts: 685 Loc: Malibu CA, USA	Big Jim, good question Has Randall ever make sterile knives? Certainly many other manufacturers have, for SOG, CIA and OSS etc. Griff RKS #63 _________________________ G Snyder RKS #63 RKCC "REMEMBER, YOU CAN NEVER GO WRONG BY COLLECTING OR OWNING THE BEST" http://www.knife-collectibles.com
Top

#25755 - 09/30/07 06:21 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: boardrider]
BoBlade Knife Enthusiast Registered: 09/13/05 Posts: 1673 Loc: Kalifornia	Quote: Is the handle pinned ivory in your opinion? It sure looks like it but how often do you see this vintage of ivory that crack/check free, it usually cracks at the pin at least usually more. Also what do you think of the shape of the handle? The blade looks right to me but no trademark? All in all more questions than answers. The kids in my neighborhood would call this "one Killer knife" pun intended. Griff Snyder RKS #63 Hi Griff, IMO the knife was made by the shop and the handle is the shop's old Belgium Congo ivory. I've seen a few ivory handles that old in similar condition as well as that shape. Quote: Ron, A wild guess. Could the knife have been ordered from the shop"sterile"? GOD BLESS OUR TROOPS!!! Jim, I think that's as good a guess as they come. There were kit knives back in the early / mid 50's that were not marked kit and there must have been a few blades that got out the back door, but these were still likely stamped with the trademark given the early stage this step is done. Prior to the Dec '53 True magazine article Bo was hurting for business and I wouldn't be surprised if he accepted an order for a sterile knife. Again, ALL speculation! _________________________ Ron Mathews RKS No. 4223
Top

#25756 - 09/30/07 06:39 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: BoBlade]
crutchtip Knife Enthusiast Registered: 11/16/05 Posts: 2851	I was gonna post this a bit ago prior to Ron's but I think it applies from what I know. This could be an early "backdoor" knife, built perhaps by/for an employee? Maybe it was a project knife of an employee with permission from Bo. Maybe it was made for a "spook" during the Viet Nam war. I could come up with allot of maybes. Really hard to say. I don't think it a "kit" knife as it would/should have the RMK logo stamp. The blade is a later blade grind, as early as the mid 60's, but that is where it ends. From the hilt back, it is in appearance at least, as early as the 50's and even late 40's in some respects. The blade will carry the day though for dating purposes. All we can go on though is as it stands from memory of past employees, shop records, and Randall family members, is that every authorized blade to come out of the RMK shop since sometime mid/late 1939 should have had a logo stamp. This one does appear to be an exception. Definitely an interesting study.
Top

#25757 - 09/30/07 06:49 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: crutchtip]
boardrider Knife Enthusiast Registered: 01/12/06 Posts: 685 Loc: Malibu CA, USA	So then the conclusion is that this knife is for sure a Randall as confirmed by two of the most knoledgeable here? WOW! Griff Snyder #63 _________________________ G Snyder RKS #63 RKCC "REMEMBER, YOU CAN NEVER GO WRONG BY COLLECTING OR OWNING THE BEST" http://www.knife-collectibles.com
Top

#25758 - 09/30/07 07:53 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: boardrider]
crutchtip Knife Enthusiast Registered: 11/16/05 Posts: 2851	I should have added Griff, that is IF it is a Randall blade. I don't know that it is. Without a hands on examination, it would be hard to make an honest determination. You have to remember, there were/are many talented knife makers out there.
Top

#25759 - 09/30/07 08:32 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: crutchtip]
BoBlade Knife Enthusiast Registered: 09/13/05 Posts: 1673 Loc: Kalifornia	Joe, I see what you mean about the blade grind: Early 50's would have deeper choils. Too bad we'll probably never know the story behind this one. _________________________ Ron Mathews RKS No. 4223
Top

#25760 - 10/01/07 09:58 AM Re: This Old Randall [Re: BoBlade]
Sheldon_Wickersham Knife Enthusiast Registered: 09/14/05 Posts: 868 Loc: Montana	_________________________ If all else fails, punt...
Top

#25761 - 10/01/07 12:40 PM Re: This Old Randall [Re: BoBlade]
BigJim Knife Enthusiast Registered: 05/03/06 Posts: 1054	Here's a nice old #1-6.Hope you enjoy.Great knives posted so far.Thanks for keeping it going. GOD BLESS OUR TROOPS!!! Attachments 25564-IMG_08141-6-2.jpg (490 downloads) Edited by BigJim (10/01/07 12:47 PM) _________________________ Jim P. NRA Life The Only Place I want to see a liberal is in a Museum
Top

Page 9 of 171

9

View All Topics

Hop to:

Moderator: Mr_Mod